Proposal to ban organizations from requiring people to wear facial coverings is drawing fire from local businesses.
Published: 2021-02-24 05:14 pm
Businesses oppose N. Dakota bill that would ban mask mandates

A North Dakota lawmaker may have gotten more than he bargained for when the legislature on Monday approved his proposal to ban requirements for wearing face masks in the state, where more than 1,400 residents have died of COVID-19. That's because of disagreement over what the proposed law would actually do.

The bill, now on its way to the state Senate, would bar state and local officials, schools and businesses from mandating masks, according to local news reports and to the Greater North Dakota Chamber (GNDC), the biggest statewide business advocacy group, which opposes the anti-masking measure.

"Our intent is to oppose it in the Senate," Matt Gardner, GNDC's legislative director, told CBS MoneyWatch. "A business needs to be able to protect its customers and employees how it sees fit."

The bill's sponsor, state representative Jeff Hoverson, stated in an email to CBS MoneyWatch that the measure would only impact "government entities." Yet the one-page bill, notable for its brevity, includes a subsection that "prohibits making use of a face mask, shield or covering a condition for entry, education, employment or services." 

The section "does not appear to prohibit a private business from making use of a mask a condition for entry or employment; however, state or local government may not make use of a mask a condition for entry to a business," Hoverson said in the email, citing legislative council attorneys. 

Others disagreed, including Gardner at GNDC. "To us that means entry — it could be into a grocery store, any business," Gardner said, noting that could also include a food manufacturer where workers wear masks for hygienic reasons and to keep products safe.

CDC issues mask requirement for all public tr... 10:05

One academic expert had a similar read on the measure, calling it overly broad. "As it is now, it prohibits anybody to require masks be worn," said Robert Wood, a professor at the University of North Dakota.

Hoverson's proposal "precludes any business from operating within the state from requiring face coverings as a criteria for entry," said Wood, a professor of political science and public administration. Such a law would go against "the whole rationale behind 'no shoes, no shirt, no service,' where as a matter of public safety a business is allowed to discriminate based on reasonable public health accommodations," Wood said.

In theory, a chain like Walmart with a nationwide mask mandate would have to adhere to the proposal should it become law in North Dakota, said Wood, who noted the retailer complied with other state and local ordinances. As of last year, there were 14 Walmart stores in North Dakota. 

Reached for comment, Walmart cited Hoverson's take on his measure in stating it did not believe it would be impacted and declined further comment on the matter. 

In arguing for his bill, Hoverson cast mask requirements as part of a broad conspiracy by "unelected, wealthy bureaucrats who are robbing our freedoms and perpetuating lies."

Read Full Story

Terror cell link - 2 weeks ago
Col. Jeff McCausland (Ret.), CBS News Military Consultant, discuss Paris massacre terrorists receiving $20,000 from al Qaeda in Yemen.
Read More

Subway terror threat; Executioner identified - 3 weeks ago
Maj. Mike Lyons (Ret.), CBS News Military Analyst, discusses the alleged ISIS subway plot and the FBI director revealing they know the identity of the masked ISIS executioner of two U.S. journalists.
Read More

12/15: Los Angeles schools shut down over bomb hoax; Grandma cleans up mean streets of Milwaukee - 1 day ago
Los Angeles officials defended a decision to close the entire school system Tuesday in response to a terrorism threat that turned out to be fake; Jericka Duncan reports from Buffalo, N.Y., where residents have been grabbing their golf clubs instead of sno
Read More

Musk on the loans critical to Tesla's survival - 4 weeks ago
Tesla Motors CEO Elon Musk tells Scott Pelley about paying back a loan from U.S. taxpayers early and with interest
Read More